Teleconference 2015-06-29 14:00 UTC

https://plus.google.com/hangouts/_/g32giwnw3t5eqysbfveh5sd2lma

Present:

Syd Bauman (SB)
Lou Burnard (LB)
Hugh Cayless (HC)
Fabio Ciotti (FC)
Stefan Majewski (SM)
Raff Viglianti (RV)
Paul Schaffner (PFS)
Peter Stadler (PWS)
James Cummings (JC @ 14:08 - 14:44)

Apologies:

Martin Holmes
Stefanie Gehrke

Critical Apparatus Report

HC reports that SB’s off-the-cuff proposal in Ann Arbor doesn’t work well.
HC also reports that MH balked at the idea of multiple different <app> elements for different levels.
Group wondered if OP (Marjorie B) wanted to break abstract model or not, so they asked. She does not.
SB suggests method used for “odd4odds” may help generate rules to check for violations
[SB suggests a name for the issue: “the director’s cut problem”]
SB suggests one criterion: post-processing, each witnesses encoding must not break abstract model. If there is non-parallelism between <rdg>s, that’s your problem. ‘Post-Processing’ could be anything though, so JC argues it needs to be more direct: if you choose one or other of the lem/rdg it should validate.
Action on SB to experiment with validation scenarios.

Status report on Standoff

Council working group (PFS, LB, MH, FC, SM, PWS) created an alternative proposal as the "Ann Arbor" branch at https://github.com/laurentromary/stdfSpec/tree/AnnArbor
Laurent and Peter will flesh out examples and documentary prose

Bug 751 (SB)

http://sourceforge.net/p/tei/bugs/751/

Problem: detailed classes or just one?
For now just one, SB to implement (by merging for-bug-751/ branch into trunk) soon

<xenoData> (SB)

Checked in and working in a different branch. Ready to check in to trunk? Action on SB: generate a copy of Guidelines HTML with <xenoData> for people to read.

Schematron 1.x (SB)

SB sent an email to TEI-L this morning asking for usage stats of non-ISO-schematron

Fall F2F update

HC still in discussion w/ Emmanuelle but building is closed on Sun 10-25, so we’d have to find our own meeting room. Perhaps in the hotel? Action on HC to check on hotel and possibility of reserving a conference room there.

Next release

Before TEI Members’ Meeting in Lyon. SB suggests last week Sept, 1st week Oct; which means we’ll have a conference call right near release.

xenoData
app(?)
standOff(?)
org
msFrag

Pure ODD

Lou blocked due to a problem with the implementation of dataSpec
Yes, we do plan to continue to support RNG-ODD even after PureODD is available, at least for some time.
Need to talk soon about when to switch to new datatype definition method.